Rank Player Team PIM
1 D. Phaneuf Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 144
2 C. Orr Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 110
3 D. Clarkson Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 93
4 F. McLaren Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 77
5 N. Kadri Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 67
6 T. Gleason Carolina Hurricanes CAR 55
7 J. van Riemsdyk Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 50
8 J. Lupul Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 44
9 P. Ranger   36
10 C. Gunnarsson St. Louis Blues STL 34
11 M. Fraser New Jersey Devils NJD 33
12 J. McClement Carolina Hurricanes CAR 32
13 C. Franson Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 30
14 P. Kessel Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 27
15 T. Bodie Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 26
16 N. Kulemin New York Islanders NYI 24
17 D. Bolland Florida Panthers FLA 24
18 M. Raymond Calgary Flames CGY 22
19 J. Gardiner Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 19
20 C. Ashton Toronto Maple Leafs TOR 19